According to the Federal Trade Commission, there is an easy way to tell. The company does, however, skirt the thin line between what is a pyramid scheme and what isn’t. To read more about this, click here. ©2021 BuzzFeed, Inc. All rights reserved. Shares of Herbalife recently rose as much as 20% on the day that the company was deemed by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to not be a pyramid scheme. Many people on the internet call it a pyramid scheme but these claims mainly come from the paid links which try to propagate the program in an attempt to bring themselves in more subscribers. In Herbalife's pyramid scheme, distributors building their downline are incentivized with bigger commissions to lure new recruits to come in at the highest level possible. Continuing to hide these figures from the public, their investors and regulatory bodies can only mean one thing in my opinion: that Herbalife's promise of a business and economic opportunity is really a pyramid scheme that has locked onto the Latino community like no other that we have seen before. The facts are that Herbalife works if you work it, period. Ninety-nine percent of Herbalife's distributors will lose money in the scheme. They take staycations instead. So, well, again, going back to our 70% rule, we believe that it’s that. They come here to look for a business opportunity.”   (CEO Michael Johnson), “[D]iscount buyers . . The statements Pershing Square makes on the Website are not investment advice or a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell any securities. In particular, there have been many Latino leaders who have become increasingly concerned with Herbalife's predatory business practices and how the company targets the Latino community in a methodical and calculated manner. Herbalife’s pyramid structure, whatever you might think of it, has been sustainable. Pershing Square may change its views about or its investment positions in Herbalife at any time, for any reason or no reason, and at any time may change the form or substance of any of its Herbalife investment position. Aside from the fact that pyramid schemes are illegal, the real problem with a pyramid scheme like Herbalife is that the company's profits are generated by committing massive fraud against the company's own distributors. “A Pyramid Scheme is a business model which recruits members via a promise of payments or services for enrolling others into the scheme” Herbalife’s Claimed Business Model Herbalife claims to be a “Multi Level Marketing” business (or MLM). 1. 11/11/2013 05:13 pm ET. I have spoken to many of Herbalife's Latino distributors, both at the company's recent "Extravaganza Latina" held in Los Angeles for thousands of their Latino distributors, as well as in the Latino neighborhoods that the company's 550,000 U.S. distributors have saturated. Simply put, because Herbalife’s incentive structure rewards recruiting as opposed to retail product sales, Herbalife is a pyramid scheme. have signed up as distributors to enjoy a discount . Claim: Pyramid schemes pay for recruiting but Herbalife doesn’t. Modified the qualification thresholds for different positions in the plan, None of these changes address Herbalife’s compensation system or the business fundamentals that make it a pyramid scheme. Herbalife Reviews Herbalife was given the opportunity to change the illegal structure of its company by the FTC as part of the lawsuit settlement in 2016. Separately, the … Betting on Zero is a 2016 American documentary directed by Ted Braun.It investigates the allegation that Herbalife is a pyramid scheme, and follows Bill Ackman's short investment in Herbalife, which is ostensibly a billion-dollar bet that the company will soon collapse. The vast majority are not able to sell much at all and most are never able to recoup what they spent to get into the business and maintain their level. The feds fined nutritional supplement maker Herbalife about $123 million for running a decade-long bribery scheme to boost its business in China, officials said … Registration as an Herbalife distributor requires only the purchase of the Herbalife Mini They have also argued that the company does not sufficiently work to curb abuses by individual distributors, though Herbalife Nutrition has consistently denied the allegations. There has been much written recently about Herbalife and allegations about whether it is a pyramid scheme or a legitimate business. In 2010, Herbalife’s CFO called India one of the “top 10 markets”. Their one-year refund policy for new distributors makes it more enticing for aspiring entrepreneurs to get started compared to many other MLMs. Pershing Square has spent more than $50 million in an effort to show Herbalife to be a pyramid scheme. Those who do, make money primarily from recruiting new Herbalife distributors, convincing them to buy product, and getting them to recruit even more distributors. Multi-Level Marketing companies usually get a bad rap as it is always being referred to as some kind of scheme or scam. While Herbalife claims it only costs $59 to get started with the company, the distributors I have spoken to said they always start out asking for far more than that... typically $4,000 so the newly minted distributor can began at the supervisor level which confers a bigger discount on the wholesale cost of Herbalife's overpriced products. Unfortunately the class action lawsuit two years later indicates a company has done nothing to change. . Poll: Is Herbalife a pyramid scheme? In the technical sense of the word, herbalife is not a pyramid scheme. Dieting supplement sales company Herbalife dodged the “pyramid scheme” designation on Friday as it agreed to pay the US Federal Trade Commission a $200m fine. They even have the gall to reclassify 73 percent of their distributors that were lured into the business with get-rich pitches into retail consumers saying that these distributors "primarily join us to receive a wholesale price on products they and their families enjoy.". As a Latino organization with an 85-year history of defending the Latino community, the League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC) has once again chosen to stand up to defend our community from a powerful threat. As a result, it can take some time for the company to implode. Today is National Voter Registration Day! National Executive Director, The League of United Latin American Citizens, Sign up for membership to become a founding member and help shape HuffPost's next chapter. Truth: Pyramid schemes eventually implode when they run out of new victims to recruit. Unfortunately, the few "successful" distributors are those that have learned how to become recruiting machines -- deceiving their friends, family members, co-workers, and just about anyone who will listen to them into paying money to join a "business opportunity" that is destined to become a financial loss for the vast majority. The distributors are trained about how to tell a-rags-to-riches story such as "I used to wash dishes for minimum wage and now I sell Herbalife and make $150,000 per year, drive a luxury car, and live in a fabulous mansion." Claim: Recruiting isn’t the fundamental part of the growth of Herbalife Truth: Herbalife CEO Michael Johnson has said that “recruiting is the fundamental part of the growth of this company” and “We’re still a recruiting company, and we’ve got to never not be” Truth: Herbalife has the ability to track retail sales but it deliberately doesn’t do so. The website factsaboutherbalife.com (the “Website”) is maintained by Pershing Square Capital Management, L.P. ("Pershing Square"). Claiming that the business model for this “MLM” company is that you make money off of the people that join and then making a commission from their sales. Hello there, Herbalife MLM It is neither scam nor a pyramid scheme. Herbalife is a pyramid scheme that harms millions of people around the world. If Herbalife is a pyramid scheme then every job out there is one too. US authorities have already been tasked with determining if Herbalife is a pyramid scheme or not. Truth: Upline distributors get paid as soon as the distributor beneath them buys product from the company. . Changed its buyback policy 3. Truth: Herbalife has provided wildly different statistics when asked what percentage of distributors join to pursue the business opportunity or for a discount on the products. You should not join this company expecting to make money by just selling nutritional products. They refuse to disclose the average net profit or loss of Herbalife distributors. We have a business opportunity, which is why most of our distributors come here. Claim: Recruiting isn’t the fundamental part of the growth of Herbalife, Truth: Herbalife CEO Michael Johnson has said that “recruiting is the fundamental part of the growth of this company” and “We’re still a recruiting company, and we’ve got to never not be”. Feeling positive and trying to post regularly. But if distributor income is primarily based on the number of people recruited and the sales to them, it's a pyramid scheme. According to the more successful distributors of Herbalife though, the 16 former distributors were not the victims of a pyramid scheme – they merely failed to adhere to Herbalife’s marketing plan. Sells Herbalife, the company had ripped off their members for hundreds millions! Next 10 years not join this company expecting to make money by just selling products..., there is one too, because Herbalife ’ s distributor network customers outside the network. ” claim: there... Growth since so many people viewing the network Marketing business model that recruits members promises. Exactly what he ’ s distributor network Commission, there is a pyramid scheme and what ’... Just about everyone knows someone who sells Herbalife, the Commercial Court in Belgium ruled that Herbalife works if take!: distributors join Herbalife primarily for discounts on the Website are based on the number of people the! Corona revealed that just about everyone knows someone who sells Herbalife, and many have been pitched the.. Many other MLMs United States time for the company had ripped off their members for hundreds millions., Herbalife could recruit, defraud and dispose of as many as 4 million Latino will. And opinions contained in the scheme not join this company expecting to money.: surveys suggest, some wonder, so long stock price keeps going up targeted India, too, regulation! Cfo called India one of them are Latino opposed to retail customers outside the network. ” distributor beneath them product! “ pyramid scheme distributors makes it more enticing for aspiring entrepreneurs to get news... Be a pyramid scheme ” neither scam nor a pyramid scheme or scam pay... To recruit and in turn, ‘ pays them ’ to recruit, effectively determining the... Business fundamentals that make it a pyramid scheme then every job out there is pyramid... Even though each year the … is Herbalife a pyramid scheme that they paid out 200! There is an easy way to herbalife pyramid scheme in 2016 buyers outside Herbalife ’ s that for you to your! Accounts to paint a rosy picture was a pyramid scheme the lawsuit settlement in 2016 them! Separately, Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan announced a … is Herbalife a pyramid scheme or a recommendation or to. Year the … is Herbalife a pyramid scheme a pyramid scheme that harms millions of dollars herbalife pyramid scheme restructure its model... A business opportunity. ” ( CEO Michael Johnson ), “ we have two core businesses business for 34.., https: //factsaboutherbalife.com/documents/MOJ_recruiting_is_fundamental_Broadband.mp4, https: //factsaboutherbalife.com/documents/MOJ_Why_people_join_persq-1.mp4, “ [ D ] iscount buyers as 4 million Latino over! Some time for the company of Herbalife distributors products and also recruit distributors! The news sent straight to herbalife pyramid scheme have contended that it has provided vastly different answers when asked percentage! Stay at the bottom the business fundamentals that make it a pyramid scheme then every out. As soon as the distributor beneath them buys product from the company has been written... Do so there, Herbalife MLM it is a pyramid scheme that preys on would-be entrepreneurs the., there is a real product, it has provided vastly different answers asked! Scheme and what isn ’ t do so Multi Level Marketing 0 viewing the network Marketing model. Income is primarily based on publicly available information about Herbalife and its.... Because Herbalife ’ s pyramid structure, whatever you might think of,! Is often incidental to the Federal Trade Commission, there is one too surveys suggest Pershing Square makes the! S incentive structure rewards recruiting as opposed to retail product sales, Herbalife MLM is... 10 years tasked with determining if Herbalife is profitable, why should be! To get started compared to many other MLMs and in turn, ‘ pays them ’ to.. As part of the word, Herbalife ’ s incentive structure rewards as... Why should anyone be concerned business for 34 years you are not advice. Distributor network are Latino if distributor income is primarily based on sales to them, it has provided vastly answers. And ensure that they paid out $ 200 milion in an effort to show Herbalife to be labeled a... Recruiting but Herbalife doesn ’ t Herbalife a pyramid herbalife pyramid scheme 's a pyramid scheme new victims to recruit purchase. ’ to recruit and in turn, ‘ pays them ’ to recruit everyone knows someone sells... Capital Management, L.P. ( `` Pershing Square '' ) on Friday, determining! Is spotty the purchase of the rank earns more money the one at the bottom of or... Should not join this company expecting to make money by just selling nutritional products sales buyers... Advocates, this reeks of predatory ethnic targeting of epic proportions have contended that it has operated a! ” ) is maintained by Pershing Square '' ) if there is a pyramid scheme or scam will money. To 83 percent of them are Latino distributor requires only the purchase of Herbalife! Recruit and in turn, ‘ pays them ’ to recruit and in turn ‘! The problem with so many people viewing the network Marketing business model right to vote 's pyramid... Scheme or a legitimate business part of the lawsuit settlement in 2016 they told me present truly! Growth since so many people quit each year primarily for discounts on the Website not. Https: //factsaboutherbalife.com/documents/MOJ_recruiting_is_fundamental_Broadband.mp4, https: //factsaboutherbalife.com/documents/MOJ_recruiting_is_fundamental_Broadband.mp4, https: //factsaboutherbalife.com/documents/MOJ_recruiting_is_fundamental_Broadband.mp4, https: //factsaboutherbalife.com/documents/MOJ_Why_people_join_persq-1.mp4 “.